# AdiaUI Training Data — Visual Audit Report (REVISED)
## April 15, 2026

### CRITICAL FINDING
The initial audit used Python's http.server which cannot resolve bare ES module specifiers
(`@core/element.js`). ALL components were failing to register. After switching to Vite
(the project's actual dev server), most patterns render correctly.

**Lesson: Always use `npm run dev` (Vite) to view training patterns.**

### Rating Scale
- 1/5: Broken / essentially blank
- 2/5: Renders but major structural problems
- 3/5: Functional but needs polish or more variations
- 4/5: Good quality, minor issues
- 5/5: Production-ready golden example

---

## REVISED SCORES (with Vite)

### ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ (5/5) — Production quality
| Pattern | Notes |
|---------|-------|
| **ui/empty-state** | 8 variants across 5 categories. Icons, copy, CTAs all excellent. |

### ⭐⭐⭐⭐ (4/5) — Good, minor polish needed
| Pattern | Notes |
|---------|-------|
| **ui/auth-login** | 10 variations. Split layout recently fixed. Best ui pattern for variation count. |
| **prose/auth-login** | 7 rich compositions. Well-structured. |
| **ui/kanban** | 3-column board. Cards with tags, avatars, add buttons. Clean. |
| **ui/chat-list** | 8 contacts with search, avatars, timestamps, unread badges. |
| **ui/data-table** | Full table with checkboxes, sorting, status badges, pagination, toolbar. |
| **ui/nav-sidebar** | Full sidebar with nav groups, breadcrumbs, stat cards in main area. |
| **ui/toolbar** | 3 variations (text editor, app bar, canvas). Icons rendering well. |
| **ui/otp** | 3 variations. OTP inputs render. Timer + progress bar on 2FA variant. |
| **prose/footer** | Clean link grid, social icons, copyright. Best prose pattern. |

### ⭐⭐⭐½ (3.5/5) — Decent, needs more variations or polish
| Pattern | Notes |
|---------|-------|
| **ui/stat-cards** | 4 sections render fully. Low card-to-background contrast. |
| **ui/stat-pattern** | 5 sections. Need to verify sparkline rendering. |
| **ui/accordion-settings** | Accordions work. Toggles hidden in collapsed sections — needs expanded state. |
| **prose/feature-grid** | Clean 3x2 grid. Missing icons in cards. |
| **prose/pricing** | Classic 3-tier. Could use toggle (monthly/annual) and comparison table. |
| **prose/testimonials** | Grid + featured. Clean. Only 1 composition. |
| **prose/steps** | 4 stepper variations. Missing labels/connectors on some. |

### ⭐⭐⭐ (3/5) — Functional but needs work
| Pattern | Notes |
|---------|-------|
| **ui/breadcrumb** | 4 contextual variations. Separators may be rendering now — verify. |
| **ui/tooltip-popover** | 6 sections. Need to re-verify icon rendering. |
| **ui/theme-builder** | Nice concept. Verify slider controls render with Vite. |
| **ui/tabs-panels** | 2 variations only. Need more. Avatar may render now. |
| **ui/timeline-pattern** | 4 sections. Need to verify labels/icons with Vite. |
| **ui/divider** | 5 sections. Need to verify label rendering with Vite. |
| **ui/drawer-panel** | Decent list UI. Only 1 real pattern. |
| **ui/code-block** | Need re-audit with Vite — may have syntax highlighting now. |
| **ui/command-palette** | Need re-audit — search input + icons may render now. |
| **ui/file-upload** | Need re-audit — dropzone + progress bars may render now. |
| **ui/embed** | 3 card types. Minimal but functional. |
| **prose/cta** | Only 1 variation. Needs 2-3 more compositions. |
| **prose/hero** | Very minimal. 1 variation with placeholder screenshot. |
| **prose/user-profile** | 3 variations. Avatars should render now. Spacing needs fix. |

### ⭐⭐ (2/5) — Needs significant rework
| Pattern | Notes |
|---------|-------|
| **ui/auth** | Uses tabs + JS. Different paradigm than other training data. Only shows 1 panel. |
| **ui/ai-input** | Only 1 variation. Needs full family of chat input patterns. |
| **ui/chat** | Only 1 variation. Needs conversation states, group chat, etc. |
| **ui/notifications** | Only empty state shown. Needs populated state + variations. |
| **ui/settings** | Too thin. Needs full settings page with multiple sections. |
| **ui/skeleton** | Need to verify with Vite. May still be too minimal. |
| **ui/navbar** | 1 variation only. Needs mobile, sticky, with-dropdown variants. |

---

## STRUCTURAL ISSUES (still valid regardless of rendering)

### 1. Too few variations
Many ui patterns have only 1-3 variations. auth-login (10) and empty-state (8) are the standard.
**Target: 4-8 variations per ui pattern.**

Patterns needing more variations:
- ai-input (1), chat (1), navbar (1), notifications (1), settings (1)
- skeleton (needs clear section labels), chat-list (1), auth (1)

### 2. Prose patterns too thin
Most prose patterns are single compositions. Should have 2-3 alternative layouts/styles.
- hero (1), cta (1), user-profile could be richer

### 3. Some patterns duplicate
- ui/auth vs ui/auth-login: auth uses tabs/JS, auth-login is the proper multi-variation format.
  Consider retiring ui/auth in favor of auth-login.

---

## PRIORITY ACTION PLAN (revised)

### P1 — Re-audit with Vite (fast pass)
Spot-check remaining ~12 patterns that weren't re-audited to get accurate scores.
Patterns: skeleton, chat, notifications, settings, breadcrumb, tooltip-popover,
theme-builder, timeline-pattern, divider, code-block, command-palette, file-upload

### P2 — Expand thin patterns (needs more variations)
ai-input, chat, navbar, notifications, settings, skeleton → add 4-6 variations each

### P3 — Enrich prose patterns
hero, cta → add 2-3 more compositions each

### P4 — Polish existing patterns
Fix spacing, alignment, typography issues found during audit
