# VERSATIL Framework - Gap Analysis Quick Reference

**Date**: 2025-10-19
**Version**: v6.4.0
**Status**: 62% Complete (31 gaps identified)

---

## 🚨 CRITICAL Priority (Must Fix for Production)

### 8 Critical Gaps Blocking Core Functionality

| # | Gap | Impact | Effort | Owner |
|---|-----|--------|--------|-------|
| **1** | Oliver-MCP Agent (0-byte stub) | GitMCP anti-hallucination broken | 3 days | Backend |
| **2** | Dana-Database Agent missing | Three-tier workflow impossible | 4 days | Backend |
| **3** | Instinctive Testing not implemented | Tests deferred to end of phases | 3 days | QA |
| **4** | Cursor Hooks infrastructure missing | No isolation validation, auto-formatting | 2 days | DevOps |
| **5** | GitMCP anti-hallucination no logic | Agents hallucinate outdated knowledge | 2 days | Backend |
| **6** | VELOCITY Workflow not connected | Manual chaining of 5 phases | 1 day | Backend |
| **7** | Memory Tool (Claude SDK) missing | No cross-session learning | 2 days | Backend |
| **8** | Rule 2 auto-trigger missing | Stress tests only manual | 1 day | DevOps |

**Total Effort**: 18 days (Weeks 1-3)

---

## ⚠️ HIGH Priority (Complete Documented Features)

### 13 High-Priority Gaps

| # | Gap | Impact | Effort |
|---|-----|--------|--------|
| **9-18** | 10 language-specific sub-agents | Framework claims 18 agents, delivers 8 | 8 days |
| **19** | UX Excellence Reviewer missing | No automated UX audits | 2 days |
| **20** | TodoWrite + Rule 1 integration | Can't see parallel progress | 1 day |
| **21** | Rule 3 cron scheduler missing | Audits only manual, not 2 AM daily | 2 days |
| **22** | Three-tier workflow untested | 43% time savings unvalidated | 2 days |
| **23** | 80%+ coverage not enforced | Can commit untested code | 1 day |
| **24** | WCAG 2.1 AA not auto-enforced | Can deploy inaccessible UI | 2 days |
| **25** | Context statistics missing | No visibility into token usage | 2 days |
| **26** | 11 MCPs untested | Unknown if MCPs work | 2 days |

**Total Effort**: 22 days (Weeks 4-7)

---

## 🟡 MEDIUM Priority (Polish & Integration)

### 9 Medium-Priority Gaps

| # | Gap | Effort |
|---|-----|--------|
| **27** | RAG pattern storage not validated | 2 days |
| **28** | Percy visual regression missing | 1 day |
| **29** | Stop hook learning not codified | 1 day |
| **30** | Mozilla Observatory not integrated | 1 day |
| **31** | CLAUDE.md 17 vs 8 agents mismatch | 0.5 days |
| **32** | No /help command | 0.5 days |
| **33** | MCP setup guide incomplete | 2 days |
| **34** | Agent auto-activation not validated | 2 days |

**Total Effort**: 10 days (Weeks 8-9)

---

## 🟢 LOW Priority (Enhancements)

### 1 Low-Priority Gap

| # | Gap | Effort |
|---|-----|--------|
| **35** | Example projects missing | 3 days |

**Total Effort**: 3 days (Week 10)

---

## Prioritized Fix Order

### Week 1-3: Critical Blockers
1. ✅ Oliver-MCP orchestrator (anti-hallucination system)
2. ✅ Dana-Database agent (three-tier workflow)
3. ✅ Instinctive Testing workflow (auto-test on task completion)
4. ✅ Cursor Hooks (isolation, formatting, security)
5. ✅ Memory Tool integration (cross-session learning)
6. ✅ VELOCITY Workflow orchestrator (5-phase automation)
7. ✅ Rule 2 auto-trigger (stress tests on file changes)

### Week 4-7: Complete Features
8. ✅ 10 language-specific sub-agents (marcus-node, james-react, etc.)
9. ✅ UX Excellence Reviewer
10. ✅ TodoWrite + Parallel integration
11. ✅ Rule 3 cron scheduler
12. ✅ Three-tier workflow tests
13. ✅ Quality gate enforcement (80% coverage, WCAG 2.1 AA)
14. ✅ Context statistics
15. ✅ MCP health tests

### Week 8-9: Polish
16. ✅ RAG validation tests
17. ✅ Percy visual regression
18. ✅ Stop hook learning
19. ✅ Observatory security
20. ✅ Documentation fixes
21. ✅ Agent auto-activation tests

### Week 10: Examples
22. ✅ Example projects (todo-app, auth-system, ml-pipeline)

---

## By Category

### 🤖 Agents (5 gaps)
- Oliver-MCP: 0-byte stub → full implementation
- Dana-Database: Definition only → full agent
- 10 sub-agents: Documented → implemented
- UX Excellence Reviewer: NEW v6.2 claim → implement
- Auto-activation: Configured → validated

### 📏 Rules (6 gaps)
- Rule 1: Works → TodoWrite integration
- Rule 2: Manual → auto-trigger
- Rule 3: Manual → cron scheduler
- Rule 4: Manual init → zero-config
- Rule 5: Semi-auto → full auto (optional)

### 🔄 Workflows (4 gaps)
- Instinctive Testing: Design → implementation
- VELOCITY Workflow: Separate commands → orchestrator
- Three-tier: Architecture → validated
- Plan + TodoWrite: Separate → integrated

### 🧠 Memory (3 gaps)
- Memory Tool: Documented → implemented
- Context Stats: Documented → implemented
- RAG: Works → validated

### 🔌 MCPs (3 gaps)
- Oliver-MCP: Stub → orchestrator
- GitMCP anti-hallucination: Pattern → runtime logic
- 11 MCPs: Configured → health tested

### 🪝 Hooks (3 gaps)
- Infrastructure: Documented → created
- Scripts: None → 5 scripts
- Stop hook learning: None → pattern extraction

### ✅ Quality Gates (3 gaps)
- Coverage: Documented → enforced
- WCAG: Project configured → tests enforced
- Security: OWASP → Observatory

### 📚 Documentation (4 gaps)
- CLAUDE.md: 18 agents → 8 agents (fixed)
- /help: Missing → created
- MCP setup: Missing → comprehensive guide
- Examples: Templates → full apps

---

## Impact Summary

### Current State (v6.4.0)
- **Completeness**: 62%
- **Critical Gaps**: 8 (blocking production)
- **High-Priority Gaps**: 13 (missing documented features)
- **Documentation Quality**: 90% (excellent)
- **Implementation Quality**: 50% (partial)

### Target State (v7.0.0)
- **Completeness**: 100%
- **Critical Gaps**: 0
- **High-Priority Gaps**: 0
- **Documentation Quality**: 100%
- **Implementation Quality**: 100%

---

## Deliverable Timeline

| Week | Deliverable | Completeness | Gaps Remaining |
|------|-------------|--------------|----------------|
| **Week 0 (Now)** | v6.4.0 | 62% | 31 |
| **Week 3** | v6.5.0 Alpha | 74% | 23 |
| **Week 7** | v6.6.0 Beta | 94% | 10 |
| **Week 9** | v6.9.0 RC | 97% | 1 |
| **Week 10** | v7.0.0 Production | 100% | 0 ✅ |

---

## Resource Requirements

### Phase 1 (Weeks 1-3) - Critical
- **Backend Developer**: 18 days (full-time)
- **QA Engineer**: 5 days (part-time)
- **DevOps Engineer**: 3 days (part-time)

### Phase 2 (Weeks 4-7) - High-Priority
- **Backend Developer**: 12 days
- **Frontend Developer**: 10 days
- **QA Engineer**: 8 days
- **DevOps Engineer**: 2 days

### Phase 3 (Weeks 8-9) - Polish
- **Backend Developer**: 6 days
- **Frontend Developer**: 2 days
- **QA Engineer**: 2 days

### Phase 4 (Week 10) - Examples
- **Frontend Developer**: 3 days

**Total**: ~50 developer-days

---

## Quick Start

**To fix critical gaps immediately**:

```bash
# 1. Clone comprehensive gap analysis
cat docs/audits/COMPREHENSIVE_FRAMEWORK_GAP_ANALYSIS.md

# 2. Review implementation roadmap
cat docs/roadmaps/GAP_REMEDIATION_ROADMAP.md

# 3. Start with Phase 1 Task 1 (Oliver-MCP)
# See roadmap for detailed implementation steps
```

---

## Related Documents

- [Comprehensive Gap Analysis](./COMPREHENSIVE_FRAMEWORK_GAP_ANALYSIS.md) - Full 31-gap breakdown
- [Gap Remediation Roadmap](../roadmaps/GAP_REMEDIATION_ROADMAP.md) - 4-phase implementation plan
- [CLAUDE.md](../../CLAUDE.md) - Updated core methodology (8 agents, not 17)
- [.claude/AGENTS.md](../../.claude/AGENTS.md) - Agent configurations

---

**Last Updated**: 2025-10-19
**Next Review**: After Phase 1 completion (Week 3)
