## Accessibility links

- Skip to content
- Skip to local navigation
- Accessibility Help

## US & Canada

9 May 2013 Last updated at 20:59 GMT

### Share this page

- Delicious
- Digg
- Facebook
- reddit
- StumbleUpon
- Twitter
- Email
- Print

# Cleveland kidnap accused Ariel Castro in court

Prosecutor Brian Murphy said Mr Castro had used the women "in whatever self-gratifying, self-serving way he saw fit''.

Continue reading the main story

## Ohio abductions

- Mystery of 'kidnap den'
- Profile: Ariel Castro
- Missing White Woman syndrome
- Profiles of women

The man accused of imprisoning three women for about a decade in the US city of Cleveland has made his first court appearance.

Ariel Castro, 52, is charged with kidnap and rape. He did not enter a plea.

Bail was set at $8m (£5.1m), meaning in effect that he will remain in custody.

The women were abducted at different times and held in Mr Castro's house. One of those held, Amanda Berry, 27, escaped on Monday and raised the alarm.

The other women freed soon afterwards were Gina DeJesus, 23, and Michelle Knight, 32.

'Premeditated, depraved'

Mr Castro, handcuffed and dressed in blue overalls, remained silent and looked down while lawyers spoke to the judge at Cleveland Municipal Court on Thursday.

Ariel Castro's daughter breaks down as she apologises to the victims

County prosecutor Brian Murphy told the court: "The charges against Mr Castro are based on premeditated, deliberate, depraved decisions to snatch three young ladies from Cleveland West Side streets to be used in whatever self-gratifying, self-serving way he saw fit."

He is charged with four counts of kidnapping, covering the three initial abduction victims and Jocelyn, Ms Berry's six-year-old daughter, who was apparently conceived and born in captivity.

The former school bus driver also faces three counts of rape, one against each woman. More charges may be added, officials have said.

Two of Mr Castro's brothers, Pedro and Onil, were also arrested, but police found no evidence they were involved in the crime.

They appeared in court alongside Ariel Castro on unrelated minor charges. Pedro Castro was fined $100 for public drinking, while two charges against Onil Castro were dropped.

Death penalty possible

Prosecutor Tim McGinty said on Thursday he would to seek aggravated murder charges against Mr Castro, and could even seek the death penalty against the former school bus driver.

He told a news conference that murder charges would be based on evidence from one of the women held captive in Mr Castro's house that he had impregnated her, then physically abused and starved her in order to induce miscarriages.

Continue reading the main story

## At the scene

Paul Adams BBC News

Ariel Castro came into the Cleveland courtroom with his head down, as if trying to bury his face in the collar of his blue prison jumpsuit.

The small, wood-panelled courtroom was crowded and hot as a phalanx of cameras focused on the man accused of a litany of horrors. Ariel Castro never looked up as the prosecutor described the terrible crimes he is accused of.

Three days ago, he casually went to mow his mother's lawn before drinking with his brother. Now, long before his trial, lurid accounts of the crimes he's accused of perpetrating on his three victims have flashed across the world. His home is a house of horrors and he, as the cover of a Cleveland magazine puts it, is already a "monster".

"This child kidnapper operated a torture chamber and private prison in the heart of our city," Mr McGinity said.

Ariel Castro has been put on suicide watch and will be kept in isolation, his court-appointed lawyer Kathleen DeMetz told reporters.

The three women were all abducted after accepting rides from Mr Castro, according to a police report leaked to the media.

On Thursday, Mr Castro's daughter, Arlene, who was one of the last people to see Gina DeJesus before she disappeared in 2004 aged 14, wept during a TV interview.

Describing herself as "disappointed, embarrassed, mainly devastated", she apologised to Ms DeJesus.

The women told officials they could only remember being outside twice during their time in captivity.

Cleveland City Councilman Brian Cummins said the women had told police they had only gone as far as a garage on the property, disguised in wigs and hats.

Mr Cummins, citing police information, said the victims had been kept apart inside the house until their captor felt he had enough control to allow them to mingle.

A source told the BBC that one of the women was forced to help Ms Berry deliver her daughter, and was threatened with death if the child did not survive.

Nancy Ruiz, Gina DeJesus's mother: "We just grabbed each other and held on"

Her baby was born in a plastic inflatable children's swimming pool on Christmas day 2006, according to a police report.

Police said more than 200 pieces of evidence had been taken from the home where the three women were held captive.

They said interviews with the women had yielded enough information to charge Mr Castro.

Police said he had been co-operating with them, waiving his right to silence and agreeing to a test to establish Jocelyn's paternity.

On Wednesday hundreds of cheering people welcomed home Ms DeJesus and Ms Berry and her daughter.

Ms Berry, whose disappearance in 2003 the day before her 17th birthday was widely publicised in the local media, escaped on Monday evening by kicking the door and screaming for help, while her alleged captor was out.

Ms Knight, who was 20 when she disappeared in 2002, remains in hospital.

The Cleveland Plain Dealer reports she had complained of chest pains during her rescue, but she is listed as in good condition.

## More on This Story

### Ohio abductions

- ##### Mystery of 'kidnap den'

- ##### Profile: Ariel Castro

- ##### Missing White Woman syndrome

- ##### Profiles of women

- ##### Dealing with media spotlight

- ##### Quiet street, unthinkable crime

- ##### Captives' future

- ##### What about unhappy endings?

- ##### Disbelief on 'Kidnap Street' Watch

- ##### 'Torture chamber operator' Watch

- ##### Castro's daughter 'devastated' Watch

- ##### 'We hugged, kissed and cried' Watch

- ##### Ariel Castro in court Watch

- ##### Gina DeJesus goes home Watch

- ##### Cleveland children react Watch

- ##### Other kidnap victims talk Watch

- ##### Amanda's sister speaks Watch

- ##### What the neighbours saw Watch

- ##### 'I saw girl going nuts' Watch

- ##### Amanda Berry's call to police Watch

### Share this page

- Delicious
- Digg
- Facebook
- reddit
- StumbleUpon
- Twitter
- Email
- Print

## More US & Canada stories

RSS

- ### Rice gets US national security role

  Susan Rice, the US permanent representative to the UN, is to be appointed President Barack Obama's new national security adviser, officials say.

- ### Protester interrupts Michelle Obama

- ### US college head quits after gaffe

## Top Stories

- Syrian army retakes town of Qusair
- Demand for Turkey police dismissals
- Wi-fi signal used to detect gestures
- Sharif urges end to drone strikes
- Latvia to be 18th eurozone member

## Features & Analysis

- ### Extreme homesickness

  The adults who can't bear to be away from home

- ### Polls apart

  The Brit who took public opinion surveys to war-torn Iraq

- ### Only 3% pay tax

  And nine other surprising things about India

- ### Day in pictures

  Twenty-four hours of news photos from around the world

## Most Popular

### Shared

1. 1: 10 things you might not know about India
2. 2: Fixed fines for middle-lane hoggers
3. 3: Why Finnish babies sleep in boxes
4. 4: Woman, 102, base jumps off bridge
5. 5: The adults who suffer extreme homesickness

### Read

1. 1: 10 things you might not know about India
2. 2: Why Finnish babies sleep in boxes
3. 3: Pianist storms out over phone clips
4. 4: The adults who suffer extreme homesickness
5. 5: Wi-fi signal used to detect gestures
6. 6: Bollywood's Jiah Khan's funeral held
7. 7: Turkey police chiefs' sacking sought
8. 8: Syrian army retakes town of Qusair
9. 9: Bollywood's Jiah Khan found dead
10. 10: Man dies after crane falls onto M25

### Video/Audio

1. 1: Emma: I'm not doing Fifty Shades Watch
2. 2: Who are Turkey's protesters? Watch
3. 3: Woman, 102, base jumps off bridge Watch
4. 4: One-minute World News Watch
5. 5: New Zealand's 105-year-old driver Watch
6. 6: Syrian army retakes town of Qusair Watch
7. 7: Thought-powered helicopter takes off Watch
8. 8: Czech towns 'under water' after floods Watch
9. 9: Bizet gets the Bollywood treatment Watch
10. 10: Demand for Turkey police dismissals Watch

## Elsewhere on the BBC

- ### My City: Havana

  What is life like in the colourful and character-filled capital of Cuba?

## Programmes

- ### Fast Track Watch

  Rajan Datar visits the Chota Valley where many of Ecuador’s best footballers are born

## BBC links

- - Mobile site
  - Terms of Use
  - About the BBC
- - Advertise With Us
  - Privacy
  - BBC Help
- - Ad Choices
  - Cookies
  - Accessibility Help
- - Parental Guidance
  - Contact Us

BBC © 2013 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.